Interpretation ID: nht88-2.5

TYPE: INTERPRETATION-NHTSA

DATE: 04/21/88

FROM: JUANITA P. DAVISON

TO: DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION VEHICLE CRASH EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT

TITLE: NONE

ATTACHMT: ATTACHED TO LETTER DATED 03/22/89 FROM ERIKA Z. JONES -- HNTSA TO JUANITA P. DAVISON, REDBOOK A33(2), STANDARD 208

TEXT: Please advise me to whom I can make some input about the automatic type seat belts. I have a 1987 Toyota and have also seen this type seat belt used in Ford makes.

Please tell me for what purpose this design has been used. Is it to meet some safety regulation? Or is it some gimmick of the auto manufactuer?

This belt is a nuisance and most inconvenient. A person is not fully belted unless the lap belt is also pulled in place. How much simpler to make one move accomplish the process of being fully belted.

This shoulder belt takes away the roominess of the front. It is in the way when getting in the car with a handbag or briefcase or package which needs to be placed elsewhere in the car. I wear glasses on a chain and I have to always hold this out of the way when the shoulder belt in in position. Passengers not familiar with the action are startled and confused by it. To disengage the belt after stopping the motor and just sitting in the car, the door has to be opened. This shoulder belt requires a sp ecial unlocking mechanism in case of emergency after impact. What if that is damaged during a collision. It is much more complicated than the push button used to release the lap belt (and combined lap and shoulder belts in other cars).

This is a travesty imposed on the ones who were not aware of the inconvenience and the fallacy of "automatic seat belts". I still have to buckle the lap belt and then be ready for the shoulder belt to rivet in place when the motor is turned on. The rev erse process when leaving the car. There is so much lost motion besides all the inconvenience just fr the sake of having a shoulder belt forceably used. Of course all I have to do is take the shoulder belt and lift it back over my head if I don't want to use it while driving. But I do want to be fully belted and would like the one step method. Can I legally disengage the motorized mechanism with the shoulder belt in place so that I can just lift it over my head? This would eliminate some of the dra wbacks.

Juanita P. Davison

(P.S.) I have also been told it is not safe to wear a shoulder belt without the lap belt, because of possibility of choking!