Interpretation ID: nht68-1.15

DATE: 09/12/68

FROM: AUTHOR UNAVAILABLE; Robert M. O'Mahoney; NHTSA

TO: California Highway Patrol

TITLE: FMVSS INTERPRETATION

TEXT: This is in response to your letter of August 19 inquiring as to the certification responsibility of manufacturers or assemblers of dune buggy kits with respect to conformance with the Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standards. But the issue you raise is far broader and involves the whole area of owner-assembled motor vehicles.

You have stated:

"It is our interpretation that Federal Standard 108 is not applicable to dune buggies that are owner-constructed or reconstructed for the builders personal use."

This interpretation is incorrect. It is a violation of section 108(a)(1) of the National Traffic and Motor Vehicle Safety Act of 1966 for any person to:

". . .introduce or deliver for introduction in interstate commerce . . .any motor vehicle. . manufactured (or assembled) on and after the date any applicable Federal motor vehicle safety standard takes effect . . .unless it is in conformity with such standard . . ."

This means that the final assembler of a dune buggy whoever he is, must insure that the completed vehicle conforms to all applicable Standards including No. 108. In the case of dune buggies, this means Standards applicable to multipurpose passenger vehicles since a dune buggy is "constructed. . .with special features for occasional off-road operation." (23 C.F.R. @ 255.3(b)).

It is our understanding that a dune buggy consists of a newly manufactured body mounted on the modified chassis of a passenger car previously in use. An issue is raised by the facts that dune buggies are assembled from both new and used items of motor vehicle equipment and that there is language in the Act which appears to exempt "any motor vehicle or item of motor vehicle equipment after the first purchase of it in good faith for purposes other than resale" (section 108(b)(1). However, since the modification involving used components goes far beyond customizing a used vehicle and results in the end product having a different classification under the Federal Standards and a different purpose than the original vehicle a dune buggy is a "new" motor vehicle for purposes of the Act.

Continuing your interpretation you further state:

"However, those sold as kits or by a manufacturer are required to comply with Federal Standard 108."

Only assembled vehicles are required to conform to most Federal Standards including No. 108, and there is no legal requirement under the Act that a kit seller furnish lighting equipment meeting the various SAE requirements specified in that Standard. Some Federal Standard however, do establish requirements applicable to equipment items as well as to assembled vehicles. If a kit manufacturer furnishes hydraulic brake hoses (Standard No. 105), new pneumatic tires (Standard No. 109), glazing materials (Standard No. 205), seat belt assemblies (Standard No. 209), and wheel discs, wheel covers, or hub caps (Standard No. 211), then these items must conform to the applicable Standard.

Finally, there appears to be some misunderstanding of the certification required by section 114 of the Act. This certification is required to be furnished only by a manufacturer or distributor, and only to a distributor or dealer upon delivery of a motor vehicle or equipment item to which a Standard or Standards are applicable. No certification is required to be given by a manufacturer to a party not a distributor or dealer. Nor is there any requirement that the assembler per se certify the vehicle. This of course, does not relieve the assembler of his independent obligation to insure that the assembled vehicle meets Federal Standards.

I hope this answers your questions.

Sincerely

Robert M. O'Mahoney

Assistant Chief Counsel for Regulations

August 19, 1968

Ref: 61.A1117.A518

David Fay Office of Standards on Accident Avoidance Motor Vehicle Safety Performance National Highway Safety Bureau

Dear Mr. Fay:

A question has arisen on the application of Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standard No. 108 to certain types of constructed dune buggies.

Dune buggies are constructed from various vehicle chassis and bodies but most commonly from Volkswagens. The three basic methods of constructing a dune buggy are:

1. New and used vehicle bodies and chassis are converted into a dune buggy by changing the chassis.

2. New and used vehicle bodies and chassis are converted to dune buggies by modifying both the body and chassis.

3. Dune buggy kits are sold which are comprised of various modified vehicle components.

Vehicle owners have been converting their cars into dune buggies and then, after they are through using them, sell them. Kit manufacturers sell kits to a customer, who in turn assembles the vehicle himself. These are the usual methods of making dune buggies other than buying them directly from a dune buggy manufacturer who assembles the entire vehicle from his own plans.

It is our interpretation that Federal Standard 108 is not applicable to dune buggies that are owner-constructed or reconstructed for the builders personal use. However, those sold as kits or by a manufacturer are required to comply with Federal Standard 108.

A question has arisen concerning whether or not it is the responsibility of the kit seller to certify that the kit, when assembled, will comply with the Federal standards or if the assembler must certify that the completed vehicle complies with the Federal Standards. There is no question of the necessity to certify the vehicle if it is manufactured or assembled by a dune buggy manufacturer. The California Vehicle Code requires dune buggies to comply with the equipment and lighting requirements of California. Inasmuch as the effect of Federal Standard No. 108 on these types of vehicles has been questioned, we request your opinion or concurrence on our interpretation of the applicability to the standard of these vehicles.

Very truly yours,

WARREN M. HEALTH --

Commander

Engineering Section,

DEPT. OF CALIFORNIA HIGHWAY PATROL