Interpretation ID: nht70-1.33

DATE: 01/19/70

FROM: AUTHOR UNAVAILABLE; C. A. Baker; NHTSA

TO: Ichikoh Industries, Ltd.

TITLE: FMVSS INTERPRETATION

TEXT: Thank you for your letter of December 16, 1969, concerning the relationship between performance requirements of Standard No. 108 and the referenced and subreferenced SAE standards in Standard No. 108.

Public Law 89-563 requires that the motor vehicle safety standards be stated in terms of what is to be accomplished rather than in terms of specific designs, and that they be objective, reasonable, practicable, and meet the need for motor vehicle safety. In addition, the law required that the initial safety standards be based on existing standards.

Initial Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standard No. 108 was based on the existing SAE standards as specified in Tables I and III of Standard No. 108. In some instances, these specified SAE standards in turn subreference other SAE standards that are design oriented, particularly the subreferenced standards on bulbs, bulb sockets and sealed beam headlamp units.

As provided by an interpretation (copy enclosed) issued on August 12, 1968, entitled, "Bulbs and Bulb Sockets," bulbs conforming to Table I of subreferenced SAE J573 and bulb sockets conforming to subreferenced SAE J567 need not be used in lamp assemblies meeting the requirements of Standard No. 108. Therefore, as an example, tail lamps need meet only the requirements of SAE J585c (including color test in accordance with SAE J578a) when tested in accordance with the specified Sections of subreferenced SAE J575c.

The above interpretation does not apply to sealed beam headlamps. Paragraph S3.1.1 and Tables I and III of Standard No. 108 specify that headlamps shall be designed to conform to SAE J579a and J580a. These specified standards in turn subreference SAE J573b and J571b. The dimensional requirements of SAE J571b serve a need for safety in that replacement sealed beam units are readily available, and standardization of inspection equipment and procedures is possible.

In summary, the referenced and subreferenced SAE standards are applicable except as specifically provided by the enclosed interpretation.

With reference to the last paragraph in your letter, it is recognized that a manufacturer of motor vehicles may, as part of his contractual relationship with a supplier, require that the supplier certify conformance of the items provided by the supplier. Currently Public Law 89-563 does not require Ichikoh to certify conformance to Standard No. 108 of the lighting equipment it provides. However, an amendment to the standard has been proposed which would make the standard directly applicable to certain items of lighting equipment. This proposal would require Ichikoh to certify conformance, but only if Ichokoh were shipping such items directly to distributors and dealers in the United States. I enclose a copy of this proposal for your information.