Interpretation ID: nht88-4.20

TYPE: INTERPRETATION-NHTSA

DATE: 11/29/88

FROM: JAMES A. COWAN -- DIRECTOR OF ENGINEERING CROWN COACH INC

TO: ERIKA JONES -- CHIEF COUNSEL U.S. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION NATIONAL HIGHWAY TRAFFIC SAFETY ADMINISTRATION

TITLE: FMVSS 217 BUS WINDOW RETENTION AND RELEASE

ATTACHMT: ATTACHED TO LETTER DATED 01/09/90 FROM STEPHEN P. WOOD -- NHTSA TO JAMES A. COWAN -- CROWN COACH INC; REDBOOK A35; STANDARD 217; LETTER DATED 11/24/89 FROM JAMES A. COWAN -- CROWN COACH INC TO ERIKA JONES -- NHTSA; RE FMVSS 227, BUS WINDOW RETE NTION AND RELEASE; OCC 2847

TEXT: Dear Ms. Jones:

In a telephone conversation this morning with Marty J. Paliokes Safety Compliance Engineer for NHTSA, we were referred to your office for an interpretation regarding FMVSS 217, Bus Window Retention and Release. Our question regards figures 1 and 2 (p ages 418 and 419, CFR 49, Parts 400 to 999, October 1, 1985) of the subject regulation.

As background information, Crown Coach has developed a new transit style school bus based on our current production body shell. The current bus has been tested and certified for FMVSS 217 compliance as recently as March, 1988; see report no. 217-MSE- 87-10-TR7122-10 prepared under contract no. DTNH22-87-P-01028 for the Office of Vehicle Safety Compliance. Attachment 1 (photograph) shows the relationship of the seat at the emergency exit door to the door opening in this test.

In the new bus we have widened the door as shown in attachment 2 (Crown drawing E-504-278). Attachment 3 (photograph) shows the relationship of seats with the new door frame.

Our question regards the seat back in front of the seat at the emergency exit. Aforementioned figures 1 and 2 show a two inch (2") dimension between the access regions and the seat back forward of the emergency exit seat. This dimension is noted as "clearance area around seat back, arm rests, and other obstructions". With our wider opening, the entire seat back is in the emergency exit door opening. However, the actual minimum region area between the two seats are unchanged from the previous desi gn. We feel this wider opening is in full compliance with Part S5.2.3 of FMVSS 217.

An interpretation on this matter at your earliest convenience will be appreciated. Please call the undersigned at (714) 591-0567 if any additional information is required.

Very truly yours,

PHOTO GRAPHS OMITTED